Which washing machine is better Bosch or Siemens. The best Siemens washing machines Energy consumption level

If you are thinking about what should be the best one, this review is designed especially for you. We will review popular offers household appliances from the most popular European manufacturers and professionally evaluate all practical and specifications.

I note right away that there is no difference in functional content, when compared with stand-alone counterparts. However, this class of household appliances is more reliable. You will receive a unit in which thought out to the smallest detail, vibrations, foaming. In addition, the professional integration into the furniture profile stabilizes the machine and makes it less noisy.

Advantages and disadvantages

Buying an integrated washing machine will bring you the following benefits:

• saving usable space in the bathroom or in the kitchen (installation can be carried out inside kitchen furniture or curbstones like "moydodyr" in the bathroom;
• high quality washing - machines are not inferior to their free-standing counterparts;
• the ability to choose economical models that provide basic washing / spinning modes;
• thoughtful ergonomics and safety.

Choice factors

In order not to fall for the tricks of sellers and get really best device, I recommend referring to the indicated selection factors. Focus on these parameters when purchasing a built-in washing machine for your own needs.

Download type

Among the advantages, I would note the following properties:

• complete safety against leaks. I consider this the main advantage of the model - you can not worry about the safety of operation;
• wide range of programs. The model is really functional. All implemented programs will be useful for your family;
• no noise, vibration. The washing machine is stable, professionally balanced, which is rare in built-in appliances;
• clear, logical instructions in Russian. I will say this: not all premium models are equipped with an accessible manual for use;
• economy. Given the cost of the machine itself, you can count on its payback;
• good warranty service.

However, it was not without drawbacks:

• with frequent power outages and power surges, the vaunted electronic filling can fly. You will receive an empty, expensive abandoned box. It is recommended to provide for the installation of special protective devices (stabilizers);
• lack of protection from children. Without blocking the buttons, it will be difficult for you to keep track of the operation of the machine if it has become the subject of a child's attention.

About the capabilities of the Bosch WIS 28440 washing machine in the video:

Bosch WIS 24140

I consider Bosch one of the the best manufacturers household appliances, despite the obvious mistakes that have been observed from the engineering and practical side in the last couple of years. What can be said about WIS 24140 ?

First, you can count on excellent loading capacity - 7 kg, which is important with a large family. I think good decision on the rejection of the digital display. This element often fails. I've heard a lot of complaints about it being "buggy". With the WIS 24140 model, you get rid of such risks.

Secondly, I was pleased optimal energy consumption and efficiency (everywhere class A). You do not overpay for additional "+", but you get an excellent unit in terms of resource consumption.

Against the backdrop of such an affordable price, I would note complete safety against leaks, which is reassuring. I have seen more expensive models equipped with only partial protection. You don't have to worry about accidental flooding of your neighbors.

As a result, I want to give a number of advantages:

• high quality wash. Special programs will help to complement the effect;
• good build. Lately I've been noticing poor quality plastic and bearings. After testing this model, I found no complaints;
• lack of noise and vibration;
• ease of assembly and operation;
• affordable price.

The disadvantages include the following properties:

• it will be difficult for you to choose a mode for washing delicate linen or wool;
• the lack of a display may seem inappropriate to you, but I described the advantages of such a solution above;
• there could have been more additional options (delayed start, ).

About the capabilities of the Bosch WIS 24140 washing machine in the video:

Electrolux EWG 147540 W

Buying a model Electroluxewg147410W,you get a built-in front loading washing machine max 7 kg. Intelligent electronic control, successfully supplemented with .

I would like to point out high class of energy consumption and efficiency, - you do not have to spend an excess amount of resources on one wash, which is gratifying for a large family. You can safely choose a model if children live in the house. The device is absolutely safe: the child will not be able to change the settings thanks to special protection, protection against leakage and imbalance. You will also be pleased with the overall build quality.

In general, I can characterize a number of advantages as follows:

• the ability to adjust the spin cycle is a useful option that will help you wash delicate fabrics, including wool and silk, as carefully as possible;
• multi-level security (from leaks, children, imbalance, excess foam);
• you get a practical set of programs (washing wool, delicate fabrics, express, economy, prewash, stain removal program);
• the presence of a delay start timer will additionally save on electricity, leaving the start at night.

However, it was not without drawbacks:

• presence of noise. When washing heavy laundry (for example, blankets, bedspreads, bed linen), you will feel this disadvantage especially clearly;
• I have identified poor quality bearings. Against the background of a CIP tank, this makes repairs expensive;
• after washing, it will be inconvenient for you to clean the filter. It is placed very low, when opened, water will pour out immediately onto the floor.

Presentation of the washing machine in the video:

Siemens WI 14S440

The best model in terms of price / quality ratio

You can opt for models BoschWIS24140 BoschWIS 28440. I note that the purchase of the last car will be more profitable and efficient. However, both samples performed well in practice, which is gratifying. Please note that there is no child protection. Among the products presented in the review, I can not find the best analogues, so I recommend turning to competing models - built-in washing machines Bosch either.

Review Outsiders

Model Electroluxewg147410W rather weak in electronics, constructive and noisy. Such shortcomings are inappropriate at this price. I cannot recommend her. Siemens will not provide gentle washing of linen (I'm not talking about delicate modes), - even a set of bed linen will wear out twice as fast if you wash in this device. This is important and I also cannot recommend this choice.

An overview of the capabilities of Siemens washing machines in the video:

A dishwasher is a great piece of kitchen equipment. She gets rid of the most unloved manual labor housewives. Wherein good model operates quietly, consumes little water and energy, accommodates a large number of utensils. Therefore, to compare dishwashers will be useful and will help those who are thinking about buying such a functional and convenient device.

Choosing a dishwasher is incredibly difficult. There are a huge number of models on the shelves from different manufacturers, each of which is capable of driving you crazy with various marketing tricks. There is an impressive array of features, all of which can make all the difference when shopping for a dishwasher.

In order not to make a vinaigrette from listing properties, advantages and disadvantages, you should pay attention to a small detail of the market. On the shelves, in ratings, in systems for collecting consumer feedback, several brands are confidently leading.

Others are ready to offer interesting advantages, being unable to shine and take the top leadership. And the narrowest segment is the dishwasher, a kind of “grey eminence”, which is more expensive than its closest competitors, but offers an extended set of features, some of which make it very, very attractive.

Comparison of dishwashers (PM) will be carried out according to the following principle:

1. The main direction is the rivalry between the two recognized leaders, BOSCH and Siemens brands.
2. Electrolux appliances will act as the "grey eminence".
3. As bright contenders, products will be considered various brands Europe, offering interesting functional technical solutions.

The comparison will be based on the following parameters:

• efficiency in terms of water and energy consumption;
• a variety of dimensional solutions and types;
• technological performance in the context of control systems, security;
• noise level, vibration;
• the number of processed dishes.

Destroying myths and making comparisons

It is impossible to say that Bosch and Siemens are competitors. These are trademarks belonging to the same concern. Machines differ in technical performance, engineering solutions, cost and level of technological excellence only because they are developed by separate design bureaus.

The list of countries where products are collected is also slightly different. In general, it is difficult to say with confidence whose models are better. It depends on the personal assessment of the user, which is influenced by all the factors and performance of a particular product. But let's move on to comparing product lines according to the previously formed list of ratings.

Comparison of consumer attractiveness

Bosch, Siemens are very attractive to the consumer. Comparison of dishwashers is always in favor of these brands - with a large functional content, German quality and other advantages, the manufacturer offers an attractive price. Another advantage of the products of these brands is the presence of a deployed, equipped service network. Looks good and guaranteed. It is complete, that is, during the entire declared period, the repair of machines is free of charge.

Variety of designs

When deciding which dishwasher to choose, most people immediately plan where it will stand, how it will fit into the interior and decor of the kitchen set. Here, the clear favorite is Bosch products. Among the whole variety of PMs, you can choose a model that is ideally suited for the fit size (if we are talking about built-in appliances) or dimensions (if we talk about desktop or free-standing units).

Unlike dishwashers. Bosch machines, Siemens products are a fairly standard, generally accepted size range. The same can be said about Electrolux brand products. Ambitious contenders for leadership, companies from Europe, America (Ariston, Indesit, VEKO, Burning and others) offer even less. The size range is often scarce, and the designs are standardized, expected, without interesting highlights.

Water consumption

If you compare dishwashers in terms of liquid consumption, you can display approximate statistics by device class.

1. In the full-size PM sector, Siemens wins. Average consumption rates are from 6 to 14 liters, while Bosch has a minimum of 9 liters, Electrolux - 10, the best representatives brands of Europe - 8 l.
2. In the sector of narrow models, Bosch wins by a small margin. Cars have a minimum flow rate of 6 liters, Siemens shows 7, Electrolux and others - from 8 liters and above.
3. Compact desktop and built-in machines show a wide variety of results. Here, the main competing brands are close to leadership, but behind Electrolux and some European products. So, a product from a Swedish brand will consume 6.5-7 liters, Bosch literally breathes in the back from 7-9 liters, and other brands show consumption from 8 liters.

The conclusion from these statistics is simple. If the issue of paying for water is acute and you have to wash a lot of dishes, Bosch confidently occupies the top of the ranking in the sector of full-size units.

Energy consumption level

In terms of electricity consumption in the PM market, there can be a huge variation. But the benchmark for selection is about 1 kW of average consumption per hour. This parameter is successfully matched by both Bosch dishwasher models and the closest competitor, as well as big number models from European brands.

The Electrolux is slightly better: it is ready to offer a consumption of 0.7 kW, but most of the brand's products still show a consumption of about 0.91-0.95 kW. In a word, you can trust the A, A +, AAA economy class logo printed on the cars.

Manufacturability

The choice of control system and means of adjustment can be decisive for people who prefer certain principles. Here the division is very striking.

1. Bosch offers a fairly balanced solution. The number of switches is reduced to an average, the number of adjustments allows you to conveniently adjust the modes. The indication is clear, unobtrusive. There are many models, especially built-in ones, where all controls are hidden from view as much as possible.
2. Siemens often suffers from a "Christmas tree complex". Electronic control, large bright indicators, a lot of buttons and controls - this can be said about a huge number of models. If do short review opportunities, Siemens can be called technologically overwhelmed. However, the reputation of the brand is not least formed on the reliability of electronic solutions, so you should not worry about dishwasher failures.
3. Electrolux is ascetic. The number of regulators and switches is minimal, indication on the floor is present in most models. Dishwashers look stylish, simple, you can set the desired mode with a couple of clicks on the buttons.

Among other manufacturers, you can find a wide variety of technological solutions. It is difficult to speak unambiguously about their reliability. For example, LG, Ariston protect their electronic circuits from moisture. Other manufacturers use simple solutions- Sealed touch panels and a minimum of microcircuits. But Bosch, Siemens and Electrolux are clearly leading in terms of manufacturability and reliability. The machines of these brands are equipped with leakage protection different levels, and which one to choose, it's up to the buyer.

Functional content

Listing the features that modern PM offers is a thankless task. Their just great amount. Therefore, we indicate the main trend of the market:

• products from the two main competitors under consideration will offer about 6 modes, a quick wash, an intensive, as well as an economical water consumption mode;
• many models from Electrolux will offer a special mode that involves the use of biodetergents, as well as washing in 30 minutes;
• brands from Europe will delight you with both functional and technical equipment:
  • Ariston and Indesit will please with a turbo dryer that prevents stains on dishes, Clic-Clac systems (shelves are rearranged without pulling them out of the washing area);
  • Whirpool boasts automatic water quality detection and dish cleanliness testing every 10 seconds;
  • Asco know how to heat dishes and effectively remove fat from them;
  • Candy has a special Direct Spray mode, when water hits the dishes under high pressure.

Briefly, one thing can be noted. If you choose a car that will be comfortable and functional, products from the competitors in question will offer the perfect solution. If you need a twist, you can find a suitable model, but it will not be close to the market leaders.

What can you buy

Concluding the consideration of the question, which is better - Bosch or Siemens, it is impossible not to show examples of what can be bought on the market. It should be noted right away: the models of these brands are approximately equally noisy, so the choice should be made based on personal preferences. Examples will be given in pairs to compare the closest competitors from the market leaders in question.

Bright representative trademark, a built-in model with a small width of 45 cm. There are 4 standard programs, half load is available, a delay start up to 9 hours, a maximum water consumption of 11 liters and 9 sets of dishes that can be washed at the same time. Power consumption is only 0.8 kW.

The model is ideal for placement inside furniture - after closing the door, all controls and regulators are hidden from view.

The closest competitor to the above model. Almost the same performance, except for a slightly lower water consumption of 9 liters at maximum.

Feature of the model: it is intended only for installation in kitchen set, sold without front panel. It can be chosen as an option or you can install the corresponding furniture ordered by yourself.

Medium size model. There is child protection, 4 temperature settings, 5 standard programs, a delay start, you can wash up to 10 sets of dishes at the same time and spend only 9 liters of water and 0.9 kW of electricity.

The dishwasher allows the installation of a furniture front panel, it is sold complete with a standard white one. The model has hidden control and regulation systems, is equipped with a "beam on the floor" indication.

Competitor of the above model. More expensive by 20% on average, but ready to offer half-load mode, more convenient embedding (the door works with a snap-off after pressing and may not have a handle on the front furniture panel).

In addition, 6 programs are offered versus 5 from a competitor and slightly lower power consumption (0.8 versus 0.9 kW).

In a separate segment standing cars you can note key feature range from brands Bosch, Siemens. The latter has practically no full-length models. Therefore, consider two close in price and basic characteristics compact products.

Comfortable car with good combination prices and functionality. It has 4 standard programs, 3 temperature settings, can process up to 9 sets of dishes and spend 9 liters of water and 0.78 kW of energy.

Half load mode is available, there is a delayed start functionality, full protection from leaks, noise - at an acceptable level, only 48 dB.

The closest competitor, positioned as a more advanced and technologically advanced solution. The set of functions, programs, the number of dishes are the same. But in the model, the sprinkler blower inverter motor, double rotating rocker of the upper box.

The disadvantages include some clear criteria and requirements that the manufacturer puts forward to engineering networks at home. In particular, when connected to hot water, the water temperature cannot exceed 60 degrees, and the wiring must withstand a peak consumption surge of 2.5 kW from the dishwasher.

As a conclusion

When deciding which dishwasher to buy, the first step is to go to the nearest service center for advice. Although the durability indicators for Bosch-Siemens products are at high level and only 6% of consumers apply for warranty repairs (against 15-20 for other brands in Europe and America), it will not hurt to assess the complexity and cost of eliminating problems.

In particular, for some Bosch models, the system of heating elements for heating water and the main control unit are a single set, therefore it changes completely. If one of the components fails after the warranty period, the repair will cost a pretty penny. Similar irrational solutions exist for the models of the nearest competitor. Therefore, getting advice from service engineers will not be superfluous.

household appliances such well-known firms like Bosch and Siemens occupies a significant part of the Russian market. The products of these German manufacturers have always been distinguished by quality and reliability. Both companies have an equally good reputation, so buyers doubt which dishwasher is better - Bosch or Siemens.

The developers of both companies are constantly improving the lineup and produce devices better and better, introducing innovative technologies.

Bosch, like Siemens, produces compact and full-size dishwashers. If we compare their technical characteristics, they will be approximately the same.

Both companies are working to reduce energy consumption and noise levels, which is important for such equipment.

Among the models from Bosch, there are both expensive and budget devices. This manufacturer is considered democratic in terms of price, which makes it possible to choose inexpensive model with good technical performance.

Siemens dishwashers are also reliable devices that have good functionality. They have been recognized as the best in the premium segment as energy efficient and quiet units.

Options

To determine which of the models is better, you need to consider the main performance characteristics. These indicators include:

• capacity;
• power;
• water consumption;
• noise level;
• number of programs;
• availability of additional functions.

Capacity

Dishwashers can be freestanding or built-in. Separate ones are always full-sized and can accommodate a large number of dishes - up to 14 sets in one go. For compact machines, the width is up to 45 cm, they are designed for 6-10 dish sets.

Power

The power of the devices of both brands is approximately the same - they belong to the class of energy-efficient machines with low electricity consumption. Energy consumption in full-sized devices is about 0.8-1 kilowatt per hour, and in compact ones - from 0.6 to 0.7 kW. With such devices, you can save on electricity bills.

Water consumption

The water consumption in narrow machines of both brands is approximately the same: Bosch spends from 6-13 liters of water per wash cycle, Siemens - from 7 to 13. Full-sized machines from Siemens are a little more economical - they will take from 6 to 14 liters per wash water, depending on the mode, and in Bosch devices this figure is at the level of 9-14 liters.

Noisiness

The noise level is also about the same. Both manufacturers produce dishwashers with a low noise figure. Bosch cars show decibel levels from 41 to 54, and Siemens - from 41 to 52. It should be noted that equipment with a noise level of 45 dB is considered quiet.

Programs

Both brands make the devices quite functional. All dishwashers have 5-6 programs. In addition to the standard, these are the following modes:

1. Quick wash, takes about 30 minutes.
2. Intensive is needed for very dirty dishes.
3. Economic is designed to save resources.
4. With pre-soak.
5. Delicate for fragile dishes.

Options

All models, regardless of size, are equipped with leakage protection. German manufacturers pay a lot of attention to safety, so their dishwashers are equipped with a child lock.

Developers also equip devices additional features, facilitating the care of dishes and improving the quality of washing. Almost all devices use high-tech processing methods:

• HygienePlus - hot steam is used together with water;
• simultaneous washing of dishes with varying degrees of soiling, located in separate baskets;
• Shine&Dry - zeolite mineral with disinfecting properties is used for drying;
• accelerated washing due to a short-term increase in energy.

In addition, Bosch and Siemens devices have such useful features, as an indication of rinse aid, determining the amount of salt and the purity of the water. Many devices automatically set the level of soiling and select the right amount of water for washing.

Almost all cars are equipped with a delay start. With it, you can start the device at night with a partial basket load, which reduces energy consumption.

Top Models

Below are some popular models that have high consumer demand and good feedback. Dishwasher prices are approximate and may vary by region.

Among the compact dishwashers, this model can be distinguished. Water consumption is about 9 liters per wash. The unit is equipped with a water heater flow type and has a low power consumption of about 0.7 kW.

There is a mode for heavily soiled dishes, adjustment temperature regime. The price starts from 24 thousand rubles.

• low noise level;
• delayed start;
• there is a possibility of incomplete loading.

• sprinklers may become clogged over time;
• You have to open the door to see the control panel.

Leading among full-size cars. The capacity of the machine is 13 sets of dishes. It can work in four modes, including intensive. Water consumption for a full wash of 12 liters.

Built-in child protection and delayed start up to 24 hours. The device is equipped with a water purity indicator. It costs an average of 27 thousand rubles.

Advantages:

• convenient control on the electronic display;
• good washing quality;
• quiet.

Among the shortcomings, the inability to set soaking is distinguished.

There are also pre-soak programs for fragile items. Economical water consumption - only 10 liters per cycle. The average price is 50 thousand rubles.

Advantages:

• durable steel body;
• there is a temperature controller;
• silent.

The disadvantages include the high price of about 60 thousand rubles.

Narrow model with standard set modes and a capacity of 9 sets. Works on four programs. The device has an AquaStop protective filter and detergent and salt sensors.

Managed with pushbutton switches. condensation drying. For one full load consumes 9.5 liters of water. The price starts from 28 thousand rubles.

• full protection against leaks;
• the basket for dishes can be adjusted in height;
• pre-soak.

• No outdoor panel management;
• there is no beam warning system.

The models of both manufacturers are competitive and have good performance parameters. You can decide which brand is best for you based on your budget.

Updated 02/10/2017

Bosch and Siemens are German manufacturers that, in European and Russian markets became extremely popular. True, Bosch is leading and overtaking its competitor.

About what ovens better - from Bosch or Siemens, it's hard to judge. After all, each company has in its line of successful and not very models. Nevertheless, the trend can be observed by comparing two models that are approximately equal in cost and characteristics. In our case, these are Bosch HBA23RN61 and Siemens HB43GT540E ovens.

We write down the characteristics in a table for better perception:

It is easy to see that at a lower price, the Siemens HB43GT540E oven has the best performance. There is a defrost mode, plus child protection. Recessed switches are a dubious plus, but for some it may be an important criterion.

However, Bosch should be given credit. It produces, though more expensive ovens, but of high quality. No wonder the products of this brand are actively sold and are in great demand.

Siemens, by the way, is also not far behind. As for the model we are considering, it has collected positive reviews buyers. Siemens HB43GT540E is a really high-quality and reliable oven with extended functionality. There is also protection from children, and the function of quickly heating the oven to the required temperature, and telescopic guides. Its only drawback is the slats on the sides, which get very hot during operation. They, of course, will not leave a burn on the hand, but the child will be hurt if he touches them. In this regard, it is the Bosch stove that wins.

Nevertheless, if we make a choice between the manufacturer Bosch and Siemens, we would prefer ovens from Siemens. In both cases, you will get excellent German quality, but the Siemens model will cost less and at the same time it will be more functional and with better characteristics.

Remember: this comparison is very subjective, because we considered only one model from each manufacturer. There is a possibility that we picked up an unsuccessful oven from Bosch and quite a good one from Siemens.

(No ratings yet)